Open ViolationsA public record project
/

239 East 58 Street, Manhattan

BIN 1038632BBL 1013320019Block 1332 · Lot 19Built 19045 storiesGoogle Maps & Street View ↗Tax & zoning on NYC.gov ↗
Export CSV
OverviewHealth scoreTimelineFinesOwnership historyFinancingOwnerRelated

239 East 58 Street at a glance

239 East 58 Street, Manhattan has 32 open city records on file, 17 of them Class C (immediately hazardous), and no balance recorded as due on OATH/ECB summonses. No marshal evictions are on record for this building. It last sold on Dec 10, 2008 for $1,000,000. The most recent record is dated Apr 9, 2026.

Open Class C
17
Immediately hazardous — click to see them
Open Class B
12
Hazardous — click to see them
Open Class A
3
Non-hazardous — click to see them
Fines due
$0.00
Balance on OATH/ECB summonses
Open per unit
2.00
16 residential units · NYC average 0.31
Evictions
0
No marshal evictions on record
Permits on file
19
Construction permits filed with DOB
Last activity
Apr 9, 2026
HPD record

Health score for 239 East 58 Street

A composite of the public indicators below. How it is scored.

D
Health score · Sep 11, 2026
Scored from all 180 public records for this building
Scored from city records as published, which lag reality by a day or two, and closed violations rest on owner self-certification. A grade summarizes the public record, not the building itself. Full methodology · report a problem
Open Class C violations
Immediately hazardous, uncertified
This building 17
Open Class B violations
Hazardous
This building 12
Heat & hot water records
Violations and complaints, last 24 months
This building 2
Unpaid penalties
OATH/ECB summonses with balance due
This building $0
Bedbug filings with infestations
Annual LL69 filings on record
This building 0
Tenant litigation
Open HP actions in Housing Court
This building 0
Active vacate order
HPD or FDNY order to vacate, still in effect
This building No

Record timeline for 239 East 58 Street

180 records on file, every agency interleaved. Class A, B and C are HPD’s hazard tiers: C is immediately hazardous, A and B explained here.

Download this timeline (CSV) →

OATH / ECB summonses & fines at 239 East 58 Street

No balance is recorded as due across the 24 summonses below, out of $9,125.00 in penalties imposed. Balances are as the city publishes them; a settlement or write-off that never reached the dataset will not show here. New to these? How an OATH summons becomes a penalty, explained.

OATH and ECB summonses for 239 East 58 Street
048565275RAug 23, 2024STORAGE OF RECEPTACLES PLACED OUT PRIOR TO 8PM WITHOUT A RECEPTACLEJan 10, 2025Pending
048438917HMay 10, 2024STORAGE OF RECEPTACLES PLACED OUT PRIOR TO 8PM WITHOUT A RECEPTACLENov 8, 2024Pending
048210835NJan 12, 2024STORAGE OF RECEPTACLES PLACED OUT PRIOR TO 8PM WITHOUT A RECEPTACLEApr 12, 2024Pending
0702452621Sep 20, 2020FAILURE TO PERMANENTLY RESTORE CUT WITHIN REQUIRED TIMENov 2, 2020Defaulted (did not respond)
011591260KDec 6, 2018GENERAL MAINTENANCEJan 23, 2019Found in violation
035242298LJul 18, 2018OCCUPANCY CONTRARY TO THAT ALLOWED BY C OF O OR BUILDING DEPT RECORDSFeb 27, 2019Found in violation
0197492489Feb 18, 2018LOOSE RUBBISHApr 16, 2018Found in violation
044460657XJun 13, 2016STORAGE OF RECEPTACLES - 3RD OFFENSEJul 15, 2016Pending
043435727LMar 18, 2016STORAGE OF RECEPTACLES - 2ND OFFENSEMay 27, 2016Found in violation
0189112413Nov 14, 2015DIRTY SIDEWALK DIRTY AREADec 14, 2015SETTL IN-VIO
043504010KJun 5, 2014POSTING OF SIGN PERMIT, WASTE REMOVALJun 20, 2014Found in violation
041488025NMay 20, 2014FAILURE TO PROPERLY PUT RECYCS OUT FOR COLLECTION 1TO8DWELLING UNITSJun 20, 2014Pending
042352433XMar 8, 2014FAILURE TO PROPERLY PUT RECYCS OUT FOR COLLECTION 1TO8DWELLING UNITSApr 8, 2014Defaulted (did not respond)
043340194XMay 4, 2013FAILURE TO PROPERLY PUT RECYCS OUT FOR COLLECTION 9+ DWELLING UNITSJun 4, 2013Defaulted (did not respond)
0179525720Aug 3, 2011FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF DOT PERMITSOct 31, 2011Pending
0179749662Jul 27, 2011DOING NON-EMERGENCY WORK WITH AN EMERGENCY AUTHORIZATION NUMBERSep 14, 2011Found in violation
0173842103May 1, 2010FAILURE TO PROPERLY PUT RECYCLABLES OUT FOR COLLECTIONJun 4, 2010Found in violation
0159136102Feb 9, 2008FAILURE TO CLEAN 18 INCHES INTO STREETMar 10, 2008Pending
0158880572Dec 15, 2007NON-RECYCLABLES LEFT IN RECYCLING CONTAINER FOR COLLECTIONJan 14, 2008Defaulted (did not respond)
0131854948Nov 16, 2002NON-RECYCLABLES LEFT IN RECYCLING CONTAINER FOR COLLECTIONDec 27, 2002Written off
0117804070Dec 13, 2000DIRTY SIDEWALKFeb 6, 2001Written off
0116173980Sep 12, 2000RECYCLABLES PLACED FOR COLLECTION WITH NON-RECYCLABLESOct 18, 2000Written off
0115883186May 20, 2000NON-RECYCLABLES LEFT IN RECYCLING CONTAINER FOR COLLECTIONJun 20, 2000Written off
0111296718Sep 18, 1999NON-RECYCLABLES LEFT IN RECYCLING CONTAINER FOR COLLECTIONSep 27, 2000Written off

Ownership history for 239 East 58 Street

Every deed the City Register has recorded against this building’s tax lot (BBL 1013320019), newest first. A price is the consideration stated on the deed; transfers between related parties, into an LLC, or by a referee often record none, shown as “—”. Each row links to the document in ACRIS.

Recorded deeds for 239 East 58 Street
Oct 30, 2017Nov 20, 2017I.R. 237-239 E. 58th LLCRakoff, Steven, Rakoff, Jamie, Rakoff, Eric, Irving Rakoff Revocable Trust Dated April 2 1996DeedView ↗
Dec 10, 2008Mar 10, 2009$1,000,000237 East 58 LLCMarolda, RalphDeedView ↗
Jun 20, 2007Nov 20, 2008Steven Rakoff, Eric Rakoff As Trustee, Jamie Rakoff As Trustee, Irving Rakoff Revocable Trust Dated April 2, 1996Eric Rakoff As Executor, Jamie Rakoff As Executor, Steven Rakoff As Executor, Estate Of Irving RakoffDeedView ↗
Apr 15, 1985May 20, 1985Rakoff, Irving, Marolda, RalphCarter, John O Lwt, Carter, William J Ind&Tr, Carter, James E Ind&Tr, Carter, Donald B Ind&TrDeedView ↗
Jan 19, 1976Carter, Donald B Tr, Carter, William J Tr, Carter, John O Decdtr, Carter, James E TrLysander Realty Co INCDeedView ↗
Jan 19, 1976Carter, Donald B, Carter, James E, Carter, William JCarter, Sara B Decdtr, Carter, William J TrDeedView ↗
Jan 19, 1976Carter, John Decd Tr, Carter, James E Tr, Carter, Donald B Tr, Carter, William J TrCarter, John O DecdexDeedView ↗
Jan 19, 1976Lysander Realty Co INCCarter, James E Tr, Carter, William J Tr, Carter, Donald B Tr, Carter, John O DecdtrDeedView ↗
Dec 20, 1967Cater John O EtalJoc Rlty CpDeedView ↗
Dec 18, 1967Joc Rlty CpCarter John O EtalDeedView ↗

Financing record for 239 East 58 Street

Mortgages recorded against this building’s tax lot, with the satisfactions that paid them off and the assignments that moved them between lenders, from the City Register (ACRIS). A satisfaction usually records no amount, shown as “—”.

Recorded financing documents for 239 East 58 Street
Mar 12, 2008Satisfaction of mortgageHome Savings Bank S/B/M, The Bowery Savings Bank, Home Savings Of America Fsb F/K/A, Washington Mutual Bank S/B/MView ↗
Mortgage assignment63 Associates, INC.View ↗
Mortgage assignmentRanzer DavidView ↗
Mortgage assignmentMiller KennethView ↗
Mortgage assignmentMiller AliceView ↗
Mortgage assignmentRanzer RannyView ↗
MortgageHebron Rlty CpView ↗
MortgageBowery Sav BnkView ↗
MortgageBowery Sav BnkView ↗
Mortgage assignmentBowery Sav BnkView ↗

Lender names are as recorded; the current holder of a loan can differ if a later assignment was never recorded.