OpenViolations
/

15 Park Row

ManhattanBIN 1001249
2 open Class CHPD registration valid
Export CSV
OverviewHealth scoreTimelineFinesOwner

15 Park Row at a glance

15 Park Row, Manhattan has 7 open city records on file, 2 of them Class C (immediately hazardous), and no balance recorded as due on OATH/ECB summonses. The most recent record is dated Dec 1, 2025.

Open Class C
2
Immediately hazardous
Open Class B
5
Hazardous
Open Class A
0
Non-hazardous
Fines due
$0.00
Balance on OATH/ECB summonses
Permits on file
152
DOB permit records
Last activity
Dec 1, 2025
Bedbugs record

Health score for 15 Park Row

A composite of public indicators. Every input is a public record. See the full methodology.

C
Health score · Aug 4, 2026
Scored from the 300 most recent of 1,064 public records for this building
Open Class C violations
Immediately hazardous, uncertified
This building 2
Open Class B violations
Hazardous
This building 5
Heat & hot water records
Violations and complaints, last 24 months
This building 0
Unpaid penalties
OATH/ECB summonses with balance due
This building $0
Bedbug filings with infestations
Annual LL69 filings on record
This building 2
Tenant litigation
Open HP actions in Housing Court
This building 0
Active vacate order
HPD or FDNY order to vacate, still in effect
This building No

Record timeline for 15 Park Row

Records from every agency, interleaved. Showing the 300 most recent of 1,064 records on file; the CSV below has the full history.

Download this timeline (CSV) →
Dec 1, 2025
Nov 13, 2025
Nov 12, 2025
Aug 12, 2025
Aug 12, 2025
Aug 4, 2025
Jul 23, 2025
Jul 23, 2025
Jul 22, 2025
Mar 24, 2025
Feb 27, 2025
Feb 14, 2025
Feb 7, 2025
Feb 4, 2025
Feb 4, 2025
Feb 4, 2025
Feb 4, 2025
Jan 10, 2025
Dec 19, 2024
Dec 1, 2024
Nov 26, 2024
Nov 7, 2024
Oct 7, 2024
Sep 19, 2024
Sep 19, 2024
Sep 4, 2024
Jul 3, 2024
May 31, 2024
May 10, 2024
May 9, 2024

OATH / ECB summonses & fines at 15 Park Row

No balance is recorded as due across the 136 summonses below, out of $282,889.00 in penalties imposed. The city’s published records do not show whether a penalty was paid, reduced, or written off.

OATH and ECB summonses for 15 Park Row
1725484Feb 4, 2025UPON INSPECTION OF A NON ACTIVE 29 STORY ALT CONSTRUCTION SITE I OBSEROct 3, 2025IN VIOLATION
039536621LFeb 4, 2025POSTING OF UNLAWFUL SIGNS INFO PICTURES ADS ON PROTECTIVE STRUCTURESOct 3, 2025IN VIOLATION
1078744Sep 19, 2024BUILDING OCCUPIED WITHOUT A VALID C OF O. OBSERVED TEMP C OF O #:10012Jul 10, 2025ADMIT/IN-VIO
039125327YSep 19, 2024BUILDING OR OPEN LOT OCCUPIED WITHOUT A VALID CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCYJul 10, 2025ADMIT IN-VIO
012145019KDec 26, 2023FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS:FAIL TO PREVENT UNNECESSARY UNWARRANTED ALARMSFeb 5, 2025IN VIOLATION
047351190HNov 9, 2023LOOSE RUBBISH 1ST OCCURRENCEFeb 9, 2024Pending
047738153PMar 2, 2023LOOSE RUBBISH 1ST OCCURRENCEJul 7, 2023Pending
037025292MFeb 28, 2023MISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONSJun 22, 2023IN VIOLATION
1276280Feb 28, 202327-929.1 FAILURE TO COMPLETE THE INSTALLATION OF A FULL SYSTEM OF AUTOJun 22, 2023IN VIOLATION
047612308RDec 15, 2022IMPROPER DISPOSAL--BEDDING 1ST OCCURRENCEMar 14, 2023Pending
012132695NDec 13, 2022FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS:FAIL TO PREVENT UNNECESSARY UNWARRANTED ALARMSApr 26, 2023IN VIOLATION
014025108ZJul 5, 2022INSPECTION AND TESTINGAug 24, 2022IN VIOLATION
014025110HJul 5, 2022LABELS MARKINGSAug 24, 2022IN VIOLATION
047262425ZJul 29, 2021LOOSE RUBBISHNov 30, 2021DEFAULTED
1274302Mar 30, 202127-929.1 AC27-929.1,FAILURE TO COMPLETE INSTALLATION OF FULL SYSTEM OFAug 4, 2022IN VIOLATION
037020712RMar 30, 2021MISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONSAug 4, 2022IN VIOLATION
039034341RJan 5, 2021FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMJul 8, 2021IN VIOLATION
387567Jan 5, 2021NO DOOR LOCK MONITORING INSTALLED IN THIS CONTROLLER AS MANDATED BY 3.Jul 8, 2021IN VIOLATION
1274169Jul 13, 2020A.C. 27-919.1.FAILURE TO COMPLETE THE INSTALLATION OF A FULL YSTSEM OFMar 18, 2021ADMIT/IN-VIO
037019709HJul 13, 2020MISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONSMar 18, 2021ADMIT IN-VIO
039018523HFeb 27, 2020FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMNov 5, 2020IN VIOLATION
1547573Feb 27, 2020ENTIRE DEVICE/INOPERATIVE/RESTORE TO SERVICENov 5, 2020IN VIOLATION
038271618NNov 29, 2019FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMJun 4, 2020IN VIOLATION
1054055Nov 29, 201997-R-07 ILLEGAL OPERATION WORK W/O PERMIT DEVICE #1P1233; FILE APPLICAJun 4, 2020IN VIOLATION
1224295Nov 29, 201997-X-10 RESTORE TO SERVICE SO THAT FULL INSPECTION CAN BE MADE.Jun 4, 2020IN VIOLATION
038271617LNov 29, 2019WORK WITHOUT A PERMITJun 4, 2020IN VIOLATION
1651147Nov 15, 201927-929.1 A.C. 27-929-1,FAILURE TO COMPLETE THE INSTALLATION OF A FULL Jun 4, 2020IN VIOLATION
037016032LNov 15, 2019MISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONSJun 4, 2020IN VIOLATION
038270345MJul 17, 2019FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMDec 17, 2019IN VIOLATION
1224278Jul 17, 201997X17 RESTORE TO SERVICE FOR PROPER INSPECTION BY DOB.Dec 17, 2019IN VIOLATION
038270344KJul 17, 2019FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMDec 12, 2019IN VIOLATION
398290Jul 17, 201997X17 RESTORE TO SERVICE FOR PROPER INSPECTION BY DOB.Dec 12, 2019IN VIOLATION
012084962POct 7, 2018FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS:FAIL TO PREVENT UNNECESSARY UNWARRANTED ALARMSMay 22, 2019IN VIOLATION
012080404MJul 10, 2018FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS:FAIL TO PREVENT UNNECESSARY UNWARRANTED ALARMSMar 20, 2019IN VIOLATION
035256340NOct 6, 2017FILED CERT FORM APPLICATION ETC CONTAINING A MATERIAL FALSE STATEMENTSNov 30, 2017IN VIOLATION
1186212Oct 6, 2017FILE A CERTIFICATE,FORM,APPLICATION ETC CONTAINING A MATERIAL FALSE STNov 30, 2017IN VIOLATION
1108873Oct 3, 201797X10. 97X10 RESTORE BACK TO SERVICE AND CONTACT NYCDOB DEVICE HAS BEENov 30, 2017IN VIOLATION
038257648NOct 3, 2017FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMNov 30, 2017IN VIOLATION
1316753Sep 5, 201797R##)WORK WITHOUT PERMIT. DEVICE #1P1231 BEING USED TO PROVIDE TRANSPMay 3, 2018DEFAULT
038257548XSep 5, 2017WORK WITHOUT A PERMITMay 3, 2018DEFAULTED
038257299YAug 29, 2017FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMOct 19, 2017IN VIOLATION
1319917Aug 29, 2017CU-05M07; 01X10,11B07,16M07,59A09,69M07,98BB05. 05M07-CEASE USE ITEM.Oct 19, 2017IN VIOLATION
038253699PApr 5, 2017FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMMay 25, 2017IN VIOLATION
1137402Apr 5, 2017CEASE USE. 05M07 CEAE USE ITEM 05M07 MISSING LONE RESTRICTOR.THIS IS AMay 25, 2017IN VIOLATION
011558734ZFeb 23, 2017POSTING OF PERMITS AND RECORD KEEPINGMay 10, 2017IN VIOLATION
038252353NDec 29, 2016FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMFeb 16, 2017IN VIOLATION
1427417Dec 29, 201659U15,2M7,14M7. 59-PROVIDE BRAKE MAINTENANCE TAG AS PER A17.1 2003 Feb 16, 2017IN VIOLATION
038252354PDec 29, 2016FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMFeb 16, 2017IN VIOLATION
1495074Dec 29, 20162M7,59V15,14M7. 2- WWAY OUTSIDE COMMUNICATION MISSING; 59-PROVIDE BRAFeb 16, 2017IN VIOLATION
038252355RDec 29, 2016FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMFeb 16, 2017IN VIOLATION
1512169Dec 29, 20162M7,59V15,98BB7,14M7. 2-2WAY OUTSIDE COMMUNICATION MISSING; 59-PROVIDFeb 16, 2017IN VIOLATION
038252357KDec 29, 2016FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ELEVATOR OR CONVEYING SYSTEMFeb 16, 2017IN VIOLATION
1191642Dec 29, 20162M7, 59U15,14M7,98M15. 2-2WAY OUTSIDE COMMUNICATION; 59-PROVIDE BRAKEFeb 16, 2017IN VIOLATION
011463980MDec 16, 2015SIGN, POSTINGS, NOTICES AND INSTRUCTIONSMar 2, 2016IN VIOLATION
012048445ZNov 12, 2015FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS:FAIL TO PREVENT UNNECESSARY UNWARRANTED ALARMSFeb 10, 2016IN VIOLATION
011456618YAug 14, 2015INSPECTION AND TESTINGDec 23, 2015IN VIOLATION
012045084ZJul 23, 2015FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS:FAIL TO PREVENT UNNECESSARY UNWARRANTED ALARMSNov 4, 2015IN VIOLATION
012035917PAug 12, 2014FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS:FAIL TO PREVENT UNNECESSARY UNWARRANTED ALARMSOct 29, 2014IN VIOLATION
984151Oct 16, 2013FAILURE TO HAVE SITE SAFETY MANAGER OR COORDINATOR PRESENT AS REQUIREDDec 5, 2013IN VIOLATION
035032988NOct 16, 2013FAILURE TO HAVE SITE SAFETY MANAGER OR COORDINATOR PRESENT AS REQUIREDDec 5, 2013IN VIOLATION
034984888HSep 10, 2012MISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONSDec 20, 2012IN VIOLATION
942004Sep 10, 201228-302.5 FAILURE TO ERECT SAFETY MEASURES TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC FROM UDec 20, 2012IN VIOLATION
0180121866Nov 19, 2011CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS/EQUIPMENT STORED ON STREET W/0 PERMITJun 18, 2012IN VIOLATION
832049May 13, 2011FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BLDG IN CODE COMPLIANT MANNER.NOTE:THE FLR OF BATHJun 30, 2011STIPULATION/IN-VIO
034752166NMay 13, 2011FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BUILDING IN CODE-COMPLIANT MANNERJun 30, 2011STIPULATED
559112Apr 8, 2011PROHIBITED SIGN ON SIDEWALK SHED: APPL #120645392. NOTED: HAVING BUSINAug 8, 2011IN VIOLATION
034907148NApr 8, 2011PROHIBITED SIGN ON SIDEWALK SHED OR CONSTRUCTION FENCEAug 8, 2011IN VIOLATION
1662125Apr 6, 2011ALTERED CHANGED BUILDING OCCUPIED W/O A VALID C OF O AS PER 28-118.3.1Nov 10, 2011IN VIOLATION
034907146JApr 6, 2011WORK WITHOUT A PERMITAug 8, 2011IN VIOLATION
034907143YApr 6, 2011FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BUILDING IN CODE-COMPLIANT MANNERNov 10, 2011IN VIOLATION
034907147LApr 6, 2011SIGN S IN SPECIFIED C DIST EXCEED S SURFACE AREA RESTRICTIONSAug 4, 2011IN VIOLATION
034907175ZApr 6, 2011ALTERED CHANGED BUILDING OCCUPIED WITHOUT A VALID CERT OF OCCUPANCYNov 10, 2011IN VIOLATION
1036916Apr 6, 2011SEC. 1005.2 FAILURE TO COMPLY W/DOOR ENCROACHMENT REQUIREMENTS NOTED: Nov 10, 2011IN VIOLATION
957252Apr 6, 2011FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BUILDING IN CODE-COMPLIANT MANNER DEFECTS NOTED: CNov 10, 2011IN VIOLATION
927163Apr 6, 2011HAVING AN ILLUMINATED SIGN LARGER THAN 8SQ FT IN A WINDOWS IN C DISTRIAug 4, 2011IN VIOLATION
927162Apr 6, 2011WORK W/O PERMIT. WORK NOTED: AT 3 FLOOR CREATED OPENINGS IN FULL HEIGHAug 8, 2011IN VIOLATION
034907145HApr 6, 2011OCCUPANCY CONTRARY TO THAT ALLOWED BY CERT OF OCCUP OR BUILDING DEPTNov 10, 2011IN VIOLATION
896392Apr 6, 2011FAILURE TO PROVIDE UNOBSTRUCTED EXIT PASSAGEWAY. NOTED: EXIT PASSAGEWANov 10, 2011IN VIOLATION
034907149PApr 6, 2011MISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONSNov 10, 2011IN VIOLATION
1662122Apr 6, 2011OCCUPANCY CONTRARY TO THAT ALLOWED BY C/O #102871974 ILLEGAL OCCUPANCYNov 10, 2011IN VIOLATION
034896126LApr 1, 2011FAIL MAINTAIN BLDG IN COMPLIANT MANNER:FAIL COMPLY LAW DRAINAGE SYSTEMSep 1, 2011IN VIOLATION
950035Apr 1, 2011FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BLDG IN CODE COMPLAINT MANNER.FAILURE TO COMPLY W/Sep 1, 2011IN VIOLATION
927121Jan 2, 2011FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BLDG IN A CODE COMPLIANT MANNER.NOTED:A LEAK @ ROOFeb 17, 2011IN VIOLATION
034889322NJan 2, 2011FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BUILDING IN CODE-COMPLIANT MANNERFeb 17, 2011IN VIOLATION
820068Dec 14, 2010FAIL TO PROVIDE SIGNS AT JOB SITE PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION. NOTED: NO SIFeb 3, 2011WRITTEN OFF
034873140XDec 14, 2010FAILURE TO PROVIDE POST SIGN S AT JOB SITE PURSUANT TO SUBSECTIONFeb 3, 2011WRITTEN OFF
034769346LNov 16, 2010WORK WITHOUT A PERMITJul 7, 2011IN VIOLATION
956764Nov 16, 2010WORK W/O A PERMIT. NOTED AT TIME OF INSPECTION PARTITIONS IN APT 20E Jul 7, 2011IN VIOLATION
862129Oct 25, 2010FAILURE TO MAINTAIN EXTERIOR BLDG WALLS OR APPURTENANCES. NOTED: AT TIDec 16, 2010STIPULATION/IN-VIO
034769342YOct 25, 2010FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BUILDING WALL S OR APPURTENANCESDec 16, 2010STIPULATED
926862Oct 14, 2010FAILURE TO MAINTAIN: NOTED DEFECT: 1) IN DWELLING UNIT 26E CEILING COVMar 24, 2011DEFAULT
034789046HOct 14, 2010FAILURE TO MAINTAIN BUILDING IN CODE-COMPLIANT MANNERMar 24, 2011DEFAULTED
1327901Sep 17, 2009SIDEWALK SHED DOES NOT MEET BLDG CODE SPECIFICATIONS. NOTED: SHED AT EOct 21, 2010WRITTEN OFF
034808942RSep 17, 2009SIDEWALK SHED DOES NOT MEET CODE SPECIFICATIONSOct 21, 2010WRITTEN OFF
652706Jul 11, 2009SEC 28-201.1 MISC VIOL: FAIL TO COMPLY W.COMM ORDER TO OBTAIN PERMIT Aug 27, 2009IN VIOLATION
337912Jul 11, 2009SEC 28-201.1 MISC VIOL: FAIL TO COMPLY W/COMM ORDER TO OBTAIN PERMIT Dec 24, 2009IN VIOLATION
034792846NJul 11, 2009MISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONSDec 24, 2009IN VIOLATION
034792845LJul 11, 2009MISCELLANEOUS VIOLATIONSAug 27, 2009IN VIOLATION
034752702HDec 1, 2008WORK WITHOUT A PERMITJan 29, 2009IN VIOLATION
034752703JDec 1, 2008WORK WITHOUT A PERMITJan 29, 2009IN VIOLATION
752315Dec 1, 2008WORK W.O PERMIT. NOTED: IN CELLAR LEVEL INSTALLED CONVEYOR BELT. FROM Jan 29, 2009IN VIOLATION
781432Dec 1, 2008WORK W.O PERMIT. NOTED: IN CELLAR LEVEL RAISED FL INSTALLED USING COMBJan 29, 2009IN VIOLATION
365755Oct 7, 2008UNLAWFULLY CONTINUED WORK WHILE ON NOTICE OF A STOP WORK ORDER. REMEDYSep 2, 2010IN VIOLATION
034709655KOct 7, 2008UNLAWFULLY CONTINUED WORK WHILE ON NOTICE OF A STOP WORK ORDERSep 2, 2010IN VIOLATION
034709656MOct 7, 2008UNLAWFULLY CONTINUED WORK WHILE ON NOTICE OF A STOP WORK ORDERNov 5, 2009DEFAULT
792441Oct 7, 2008UNLAWFULLY CONTINUED WORK WHILE ON NOTICE OF STOP WORK ORDER. REMEDY:CNov 5, 2009DEFAULT
034700461LAug 4, 2008SUPERVISION OR USE RIGGING EQUIPMENT WITHOUT A RIGGER'S LICENSENov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
034699005MAug 4, 2008WORK WITHOUT A PERMITSep 25, 2008STIPULATED
1215069Aug 4, 2008SEC. 27-1009. INADEQUATE SAFETY MEASURES: OPERATION OF HOISTING EQUIPMNov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
1215074Aug 4, 2008FAILURE TO PROVIDE APPROVED PLANS AT JOB SITE AT TIME OF INSPECTION. NNov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
034700460JAug 4, 2008FAILURE TO SAFEGUARD ALL PERSONS AND PROP AFFECTED BY CONST OPERATIONSNov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
034700467MAug 4, 2008FAILURE TO PROVIDE APPROVED ACCEPTED PLANS AT JOB SITE AT TIME OF INSPNov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
034700468YAug 4, 2008WORK WITHOUT A PERMITNov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
1215084Aug 4, 2008WORK W/O A PERMIT. NOTED: THERE IS NO PERMIT FOR FACADE REPAIR (STRUCTNov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
1215058Aug 4, 2008NO RECORD OF DAILY INSPECTION OF SUSPENDED SCAFFOLD PERFORMED BY AUTHONov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
1215054Aug 4, 2008SUPERVISION OR USE OF RIGGING EQUIPMENT W/O A RIGGER'S LICENSE. REMEDYNov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
034700464RAug 4, 2008FAILURE TO PERFORM SAFE PROPER INSPECTION OF SUSPENDED SCAFFOLDNov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
1215052Aug 4, 2008FAILURE TO SAFEGUARD ALL PERSONS & PROPERTY AFFECTED BY CONSTRUCTION ONov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
729063Aug 4, 2008FAILURE TO SAFEGUARD ALL PERSONS AND PROPERTY AFFECTED BY CONST OPERATJan 22, 2009IN VIOLATION
034700463PAug 4, 2008NO RECORD OF DAILY INSPECTION OF SUSPENDED SCAFFOLD PERFORMED AT SITENov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
514228Aug 4, 2008WORK W/O A PERMIT ON 27 & 28TH FL DEMOLITION HAS TAKEN PLACE W/ THE RESep 25, 2008STIPULATION/IN-VIO
034699006YAug 4, 2008FAILURE TO SAFEGUARD ALL PERSONS AND PROP AFFECTED BY CONST OPERATIONSJan 22, 2009IN VIOLATION
1215061Aug 4, 2008FAILURE TO PERFORM SAFE/PROPER INSPECTION OF SUSPENDED SCAFFOLD. REMEDNov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
034700466KAug 4, 2008INADEQUATE SAFETY MEASURE:OPER'N CRANE DERRICK HOISTING EQUIP UNSAFENov 20, 2008WRITTEN OFF
21515Aug 9, 200516I10/84M11/20I11/66O2 (16-I-10)HOISTWAY DOORS DAMAGED REPAIR (84-M-11Sep 29, 2005IN VIOLATION
0139138149Jul 16, 2004LOOSE RUBBISHAug 25, 2004WRITTEN OFF
0129822716Sep 22, 2002STORAGE OF RECEPTACLESOct 23, 2002Pending
38000Jan 22, 200230Q14/52D06. 30- DEAL HOLE IN SHAFTWAY WALL IN BASEMENT. 52- SECURE BRMar 14, 2002IN VIOLATION
298789Nov 20, 2001USING HOISTING EQUIPTMENT IN A UNSAFE MANNER 1.INSOFFICIENT COURTWEIGHMay 2, 2002IN VIOLATION
302154May 4, 2001FAILURE TO PROTECT ADJOINING STRUCTURE DURING CONSTRUCTION OPERATIONS.Oct 25, 2001IN VIOLATION
0109815604Apr 18, 2000STORAGE OF RECEPTACLESMay 18, 2000DEFAULT
388983Mar 28, 2000USING RIGGING EQUIPMENT WITHOUT A RIGGERS LICENSE.Jun 15, 2000DEFAULT
177331Sep 10, 199746H,40O,410,30O,57O, 46-HOIST CABLES UNDERSIZE/40-41-CEILING FALLING Dec 11, 1997IN VIOLATION
96159Jun 6, 1995FAILURE TO PROVIDE ADEGUATE EMERGENCY POWER EXIT LIGHTS IN CORRIDORS OOct 19, 1995DEFAULT
105082Jul 22, 1993SIDEWALK SHED NOT ADEQUATELY MAINTAINED. UPON INSPECTION THE FOLLOWINGDec 2, 1993IN VIOLATION
96541Aug 29, 1991WORK WITHOUT A PERMIT. NOTED - STAIRWELL FROM STREET LEVEL TO CELLAR (Oct 10, 1991STIPULATION/IN-VIO